‘Hillsborough Judge Lisa Campbell’ Category


Florida Supreme Court seeks to Expand Criminal Discovery Rule to prevent wrongful convictions, Tampa Police Department and Hillsborough County State Attorney seek to Shrink It

On May 29, 2014 the Florida Supreme Court amended Florida Criminal Procedural Rule 3.220, the rule governing discovery (the formal exchange of information/evidence between the prosecuting agency and a defendant). The Court moved to amend the discovery rule based on a report from Florida’s Innocence Commission which made the amendment recommendation relating to informant witnesses because many wrongful convictions stem from such witnesses. If you’d like a better understanding on the informant system and its many inherent problems, please take the time to read,  “Snitching: Criminal Informants and the Erosion of American Justice.” Alexandra Natapoff, Also visit, Snitching.org.

The Florida Supreme Court stated,

“We agree with the Commission that rule 3.220 should be amended to include more detailed disclosure requirements with respect to informant witnesses, because informant witnesses are not currently specifically treated under the rule and they constitute the basis for many wrongful convictions.”

The Court did so on its own motion after its Criminal Court Steering Committee and Florida’s Criminal Procedure Rules Committee decided, in spite of the Innocence Commission’s report, that the rule did not need any amending. Incredible.

Recently the Tampa Bay Times ran an article titled, “Hillsborough cases delayed over evidence sharing dispute” The article reports that the Hillsborough County State Attorney’s office currently has a policy in place which restricts the ability of someone accused of a crime to make full use of discovery per Florida’s discovery rule. Although, the rule  allows someone charged with a criminal offense to inspect, copy, test, and photograph discoverable evidence., the Hillsborough County State Attorney’s Office, at the urging of Tampa Police Department (“TPD”), is now establishing its own “policy”. The article reports that currently the State Attorney’s office does not allow attorneys to copy recordings in drug cases involving confidential informants.  The TBT article stated, “When the Tampa Police Department asked the State Attorney’s Office to increase restrictions on who could view the recordings, and on what terms, prosecutors readily agreed.”

The State Attorney’s office justifies its new “policy” by citing to Rachel’s Law .  However, Rachel’s law was created in response to the gross police mishandling of an informant recruit (Tallahassee’s finest coerced Rachel Hoffman into becoming an informant after arresting and putting the fear of God in her).

Here are some of the casualties on the war on drugs due to the government enlisting informants as soldiers (some of these soldiers could not dodge the government’s draft on the basis of being conscientious objectors, reluctance of diming out others to save their own skin).

War on Drugs and Snitch System: Casualties

Ms. Kathryn Johnston (elderly woman)

Rachel Hoffman

Regina Kelly

Detra Tindle

Chad McDonald

Jeremy Mclean

Kemba Smith

Jason Westcott

It appears that confidential informants have a special place in the heart of TPD:

2008: Judge scolds TPD

Rita Girven posts on her FB page: “Me and my girls this is who I run with”


Thankfully, Hillsborough’s judiciary is not marching lockstep with a movement seeking to create discovery rule restrictions.  The golden gavel award goes to those judges who are able to balance the immense responsibility of rendering decisions that protect society while giving equal weight to the protection of constitutional rights.  I tip my hat off to these judges for being sensitive to that delicate balance.

Judge Daniel Sleet :  TBO: Judge Blames Law Enforcers for Dismissal of Charges

Chief Judge Ronald Ficarotta  (he opted out of joining the anti-constitutional conga line when urged by the State Attorney’s office to, via administrative rule, make its new “policy” the policy of the court system in Hillsborough.  A win for “we the people”).

Judge Samantha Ward : TBT: “Shedding welcome light on police informants

Judge Lisa Campbell:  TBO : “Court may unmask Hillsborough drug informant known as ‘Mr. X’

Judge Thomas Barber (Judge Barber presides over the pending case discussed in TBT’s article.  Judge Barber has ordered the State to reveal the identity of its confidential source.   The state has not complied and a motion for sanctions is pending. Stay tunned).

Special mention and kudos to HCACDL  and a group of upstanding gents/madams who aren’t willing to give up even an inch of due process and they rose to the occasion to resist such an effort. HCACDL and a significant number of attorneys led the charge (they submitted a letter to Judges Ficarotta and Menendez Jr.  compellingly detailing why the State Attorney’s policy should not be implemented as an administrative court rule.  Read a copy of the letter here).  The citizenry can sleep well at night that these individuals are on guard.

” The Judicial process is tainted and justice cheapened when factual testimony is purchased, whether with leniency or money.”  – United States v. Singleton


Fox 13 News Video: Judge Campbell and Attorney O’Brien’s Legal Clash, Attorney Jeff Brown says Judge’s Ruling is a “Cover Up”

VIDEO: Attorney Jeff Brown Calls Ruling a “Cover Up” WATCH HERE


In the News


Senior Judge Grube

Pinellas Senior Judge Karl Grube ordered Ricardo and Christine Lopez’s home for sale on September 3, 2014 and ruled in favor of JP Morgan in a foreclosure action. Thereafter, according to The Center for Public Integrity, it was discovered that JP Morgan foreclosed on the home even though it did not own the mortgage.

According to the CPI article, the Lopez family then asked Judge Grube for a rehearing based on this information and Judge Grube denied the request and entered a second order scheduling the sale on September 29,2014.  Lopez then obtained a letter from the new mortgage owner agreeing to a loan modification and asked Judge Thomas Minkoff to cancel the sale.  Judge Minkoff cancelled the sale.  CPI reports that Judge Grube then reversed that sale cancellation order and reinstated the sale date of September 3, 2014.  The Pinellas County Clerk online system shows that Attorney Matt Weidner  thereafter pulled out all the legal stops, he filed an appeal and stay pending appeal.  There is even an entry that reads, Def/Resp’s Motion: TO PROHIBIT SENIOR JUDGES FROM HEARING CASE. 


Judge Minkoff


Judge Thomas Minkoff cancelled the sale scheduled for September 29, 2014.  Thank goodness that the Lopez family did not have to tell the bank, “Mi Casa es Su Casa.”  Please read complete CPI article here which discusses other important issues related to foreclosure.

Reaction?  FloridaYouJudge.com




 Judge CampbellTampa lawyer Mark O’Brien wants to know why Judge Tharpe called the Hillsborough County jail to revoke his client’s bond even though Judge Tharpe is not the judge assigned to his client’s case.  According to TBT, Judge Lisa Campbell ruled against allowing O’Brien to depose Judge Tharpe about the matter.  TBT quoted Judge Campbell’s reason for denying O’Brien’s request:

“This area of inquiry would require Judge Tharpe to testify about his thought process,” she wrote, which “is prohibited by law.”

BTW, Does anyone have a legal cite for this?  “Judge Tharpe why did you call the jail to have a bond revoked on a case you weren’t assigned to, What were you thinking?” Objection!

O’Brien filed an appeal to the 2nd DCA.  TBT reports Judge Campbell did not “take well” to O’Brien’s decision to appeal.  Read complete article here.

Judge Tharpe

Should Judge Tharpe be Deposed?

Reaction?  FloridaYouJudge!

More News…..

*Former Chief Judge, Belvin Perry, who presided over Casey Anthony case, Joins Morgan and Morgan, I wonder if he will vote yes on Amendment 2?

*Florida Federal Judge: Facebook Likes are not OWNED by Page OWNERS

*Arrested US judge Mark Fuller embarrassed, entering treatment program

*Brevard judge accused of punching lawyer faces misconduct charges

*Convicted ex-judge spared shame of having to write her apologies on photos of her in handcuffs

*Novi Judge Brian MacKenzie won’t be charged with contempt


» Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

» archives



» Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

» Tampa Bay Criminal Defense

» Tampa Bay Criminal Defense